Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Healthcare Bill Changes Senate Rules - Illegally

Something amazing is happening with the disastrous ObamaCare bill about to be passed. Reid has sneaked in a Senate rule change under the guise of it being a procedural change. This is significant. Any Senate rule change requires a two-third approval, not just the filibuster proof of 60 votes.

Sen. DeMint (R-SC) brought it to the floor of the Senate trying to get parliamentarian clarification, but was informed it was merely procedural and not really a rule. How does this sound to you?
Section 3403 of Senator Harry Reid’s amendment requires that “it shall not be in order in the Senate or the House of Representatives to consider any bill, resolution, amendment, or conference report that would repeal or otherwise change this subsection.” The good news is that this only applies to one section of the Obamacare legislation. The bad news is that it applies to regulations imposed on doctors and patients by the Independent Medicare Advisory Boards a/k/a the Death Panels.

What this means is the IMAB, the Medicare review board (I won't call it the Death Panel...) will now be permanently entrenched with no future Senate able to amend or dissolve it.

While I don't believe the IMAB will actively be something like the so-called Death Panels, I do believe they will be active in deciding what is the preferred treatment or what is considered acceptable treatment and will not allow payment to treatment they don't prefer. Remember the outcry recently concerning mammograms? These folks will issue guidelines along this line. Granted, there is always some 'rationing'. The insurances do that NOW. But to have it written into law that the IMAB cannot be amended is frightening.

Is this constitutional? If this goes through it will truly be frightening! Imagine the next Republican Senate inserting language that prohibits future Senates from modifying or amending a permanent tax rate of 10% or prohibiting (insert ANYTHING here) from considering any bill, resolution, amendment, or conference report that would repeal or otherwise change this subsection.

The dissatisfaction with Congress is at an all time low and rightly so. These folks are using our money as Monopoly money, spending it like there's no tomorrow. Know what? If we don't get these people under control, we'll NEVER pay off the $14 TRILLION we now currently owe. Our children's lifestyle will be considerably lower than ours and that's a sad testament to our responsibility to provide for them to the best of our ability.

2 comments:

Steve said...

You are tight when you say that insurance companies decide who will and will not be treated now. They do. The problem is, you have very little recourse.

The government works for us, we have forgotten that, but they do. We fear them when in fact they should fear us.

There is no such thing as an amendment that cannot be changed. The whole constitution can be changed if enough people push for it until it become law.

Wouldn't you rather have control over our health care than leave it in the hands of the corporations?

MacBoar said...

I wish I could say the Govt works for us, but I have little belief in this anymore.

And I currently have control over my health care but fear I'll lose that control with Obamacare.